Q:
A:

Answers (5)

EXPERT
Lisa Bograd, MA, MFT (Marriage & Family Therapist) answered

Because a woman's identity is often strongly tied to her ability to sustain and nurture relationships, many women tend to be highly sensitive to and invested in the wellbeing of others. This can be a great strength and source of fulfillment, but it can also be a great liability and cause of emotional depletion. It sounds like the scale has tipped to the burden side for you, and as such, it's time to put some parameters around your giving. In order to preserve what's positive about your nurturing tendency, it's vital to learn how to be discerning about how you dispense it.

The first step is to look at why you feel like you have to be everything to everyone. Most likely it's because you're overly invested in being liked and avoiding conflict--again, a propensity that tends to be overrepresented in the female of the species. When your self-esteem is too dependent on how others feel about you, this puts you at their mercy.

You need to learn to be the captain of your own ship, to grow self-esteem based on self-care, self-respect and self-love. In order to do this, you need to decide where and when to draw the line of your giving and to shift your motivation for giving altogether. You shouldn't give solely because you want to be liked and fear being disliked if you say "no." You should give because it feels right to you and because you truly feel that you want and have the capacity to give. This requires a willingness to risk displeasing others, creating conflict or disappointment, and even the possibility that you might not be liked (gasp!). I know this is a hard concept to grasp, and an even harder one to put into practice, but the truth is that most people have more respect for someone who has a backbone and sets boundaries than someone who they may see as a walking doormat.

Start fleshing out who you are by acknowledging what you do and do not want. Let self-care be a good guide; retract from the reflexive impulse to give to others and first check in with yourself and your motivations. Do you really want to take care of your friend's yappy toy Poodle while she's away in Maui for the week, or are you just afraid she'll give you the heave-ho if you refuse her? I thought so! So, this means you're going to need to practice saying "no." While difficult at first, this will put you on more solid ground with yourself and others.

Remember, you're trying to build a stronger foundation for yourself and this is one of the first steps in that direction. The more you do it, the stronger and happier you'll be and the more room you'll have in your life to pursue your own desires. You might also find that your relationships feel stronger, not weaker.

I think we tend to sell others short when we sell ourselves short. So don't sell yourself short! Have faith that you can change this behavior and that others will respect you for it.

 

More On ChickRx:
EXPERT
Andrea Labis, LCSW-R (Licensed Clinical Social Worker, Certified Psychoanalytic Psychotherapist, Private Practice) answered
In addition to Lisa's great insights, might I suggest that you reflect on your possible need to be needed? What would happen if you could BE with others without DOING any particular thing for anyone?  Do you know your own inherent value or is your worth connected to the needs and wants of others that you so tirelessly fulfill?  Do you have the ability to ask for help when YOU have a need?  Remember--a genuine "no" is always better than a disingenuous "yes."  If there's a history to his--that you have an over giving parent or, in fact, had to care-take someone in your own past?  Any relevant personal history may help you to understand your behavior and grand you the insight you need to make important changes.  No matter the cause, it's important to believe in yourself; be sure to fill your own well before you give away all of the water.On airplanes, we are directed to put on our own oxygen masks before assisting anyone--even our own children.  As counterintuitive as this may seem, it makes perfect sense:  if you pass out, you won't be of any use to anyone.  That wisdom applies not only at 30,000 feet in the air; it's sensible even when your feet are planted firmly on the ground to ensure that you are in a place that allows for healthy giving.
More On ChickRx:
EXPERT
Evelyn Resh MPH,CNM (Certified Sexuality Counselor & Nurse-Midwife) answered
It seems to me that many women have two arterial roots by which they judge their self-worth - how much they way and how much they're doing for others. It's critically important to your health not to consistently put others needs before yours. if you don't there won't be much left of you to give to anyone anyway. This doesn't mean to be selfish. But it does mean to carve out time on a frequent and regular basis to re-fuel and do things that you enjoy and which have nothing to do with giving to anyone else. Try this answer out sometimes and see how it goes: when someone asks you to do something and you really don't want to or can't respond by saying the following: "Thank you for thinking of me, but I am not available to help you this time around. Maybe the next time." This isn't a flat-out rejection but it does set limits on the expenditure of your time and energy. 
More On ChickRx:
EXPERT
Michelle Brock (Certified Life Coach & Hypnotist) answered
I love the advice already given on this, but I want to point out that "too-nice-itis" is not just a woman thing (and, I think the title of this post is no more mr. nice guy). Both men and women fall into these caregiver roles, and feel like we have to "be everything" to everyone. In my opinion, this needing to please and not saying no comes from not having our own needs met, often in our childhood (or our past lives, which is my area of expertise). And so, we try to keep all of the balls in the air, running ourselves ragged in order to not let anyone down. But, we continually let ourselves down when we don't learn to make caring for ourselves priority one. This is a really hard pattern to break, and I would start with examining it within yourself. Take the others out of it and ask yourself what being that guy or that girl who pleases everyone serves in you. Does it make you feel superior? Or, in control? Or, does it feed a pattern of negative pleasure in giving to others what you actually crave and desire yourself? These are not easy questions or simple answers, but the only way you can break this pattern is to stop blaming the people who have come to expect this behavior from you and shift the focus back to yourself. Make a conscious effort to start saying no and then when you do, sit with your feelings about it. The answer is inside of you. And, go easy on yourself- lessons about self care and self love are much more difficult and represent a higher level of spiritual evolution than lessons about showing love to others.
More On ChickRx:
EXPERT
Dr. Ramani Durvasula (Licensed Clinical Psychologist) answered
In some ways we humans are pretty simple - we don't do anything unless we are reinforced or somehow rewarded for it OR if doing it lets us avoid something we don't want.  Many times we keep saying "yes" to others (even when we don't want) because it makes us feel good, it is our identity to be a "helper" or we hope someday that person will do for us (they probably won't).  But even more powerful is saying yes to avoid certain feelings - and the main thing I have observed is that people are afraid of saying no because of fear.  Fear that people will get mad, they will lose people or of other people's reactions.  Learn to prioritize and listen to yourself - you know which no's are "do-able" (for example you do not have to say yes to every time a friend asks for a ride to the airport), and which are problematic (e.g. at work).  Identify your fears - what does that "no" make you afraid of, and then take the fear to an absurd conclusion (If I say "no" to my best friend who wants to go to the movies, then she will become sullen and I won't have a best friend anymore).  Honestly, if the friendship was that tenuous to begin with - saying "no" is a great way of valuing yourself, and perhaps moving on.  Once you tolerate the initial anxiety of saying no, you will then find yourself genuinely enjoying when you say "yes" and bring your best self, rather than a resentful one, into your days and relationships. Short answer:  push through the fear, and make "no" your friend.  Best!  Dr. RD
More On ChickRx: