A:

Answers (3)

EXPERT
Andrea Wilcox (Registered Dietitian) answered

I think a very strict and restrictive diet regimen is a set-up for failure. If you deprive yourself too much you may end up overindulging and with an unsuccessful yo-yo dieting method with up and down weight fluctuations. I would say I eat healthy foods about 80% of the time and leave room in my diet for less healthy foods. This way, I don’t deprive myself too much and I don’t overindulge when in the presence of those less healthy foods or during holiday season. Eating pizza, dessert or French fries, for example, once in a while as part of an overall healthy diet is not going to make or break you. However, I wouldn’t recommend a whole “cheat day,” but allow “cheat foods” once in awhile and then get right back on track. A whole day of cheat eating may throw you off too much and make you not feel great. Also, don’t forget to include exercise in your healthy diet/lifestyle.

Enjoy once in a while! You only live once. 

More On ChickRx:
Anonymous commented
I could not agree more! I've tried all sorts of dieting styles, and this one that Andrea advocates is by far what I've found most effective.
Anonymous commented
Yes! I'm a big advocate of the 80/20 rule myself (healthy with at least 80% of your foods, and naughty maybe with 20%)!
EXPERT
Jennifer Lynn-Pullman MA, RD, LDN (Registered Dietitian) answered
If you deprive yourself of foods you really love you will never be satisfied.  This causes you to continually seek out alternatives.  Some individuals end up consuming more calories during their quest for satiety.  Including small quantities of your favorite foods is a good idea.

I agree with Andrea that a whole "cheat day" can take you way off track.  Limiting quantities and frequency of these "cheat food" throughout the week is a better way to go.  Even though you are cutting calories you still need to enjoy what you are eating.
More On ChickRx:
EXPERT
Marisa Moore, MBA.RD.LD. (Registered Dietitian) answered

Well... "diet" is a bad word in my vocabulary.  Achieving lifelong health is all about making permanent lifestyle and eating. 

So you might not be surprised to learn that I am not a fan of “cheat” days. The notion that you have to “cheat” to eat something you like sends a message that you’re doing something wrong and that you might eventually be punished for it.  Eating should be a pleasant experience with no guilt or pressure. Further, I find that people tend to overeat on pizza, burgers and desserts on  cheat days. Try a slice of your favorite pizza and a salad instead.

Instead of the cheat day model, I encourage you to develop a healthy eating plan that allows you to enjoy a small slice of birthday cake on a Tuesday if you want it. 

More On ChickRx: